thinkask.ai
Ask hard questions. Show the sources. About the Spider

← thinkask.ai home

New here? Start with a question

Questions from the Pew

The plain questions people ask a friend after a Sunday service. Each one has a short answer, two to four sentences long, and a link to the dossier that answers it in full. Tap a question to open it, or search for the words on your mind.

109 questions 82 dossiers Every answer links to its sources
The one idea behind this site

This site does not ask you to trust it. It gives you the sources, so you can check for yourself.

Every answer below is a starting point, not a verdict. Follow it to the dossier and you will find what it rests on.

  1. Open the sourcesEach claim is tied to a verse, a dated early writer or a church’s own document.
  2. Read the other sideObjections are stated in their own words, not in a version built to lose.
  3. Run it yourselfThe prompt behind every page is published. Change it and see what you get.
Dossier links open

No question matches that yet.Try a shorter or simpler word, , or browse every dossier by topic.
Not answered yet

Suggested future dossiers

Good beginner questions that no dossier answers yet. They are listed here rather than answered, so that no answer on this page points to a page that does not exist. Where the companion course already covers part of the ground, it says so.

    Reproducibility

    The prompt behind this page

    This page was produced by giving the brief below to a frontier language model with web search, after it had read every published dossier, and then checking each answer against its dossier by hand. It is published so you can run it yourself, aim it at your own questions, or ask for the answers from the other side and compare.

    Show the full prompt
    Write a beginner's section for thinkask.ai, a site of long-form,
    source-first "dossiers" on Christian teaching and its history, in
    British English. The dossiers are numbered, and each exists in three
    versions: a full dossier, a quick read, and a Simple English page.
    
      WORKING TITLE. New Here? Start With the Questions. Propose a name
      that will resonate with new readers and confirm it with me.
    
      WHY. A new visitor does not know where to begin, and may not know
      the vocabulary (sacrament, revelation, Reformation, prosperity
      gospel). The home page offers a topic filter and a full list, and
      both assume the visitor knows which topic he wants. Most visitors
      arrive with a question instead. Meet them at their question and
      point them to the dossier that answers it.
    
      READ FIRST. Read every published dossier before writing. Each
      answer must agree with the dossier it links to, and must not add a
      claim that is not in it.
    
      QUESTIONS. Write each one in the voice of an ordinary church member
      asking an honest question, in plain words, in the first person
      where it fits: something a person might ask a friend after a
      Sunday service, not an academic heading. Avoid jargon in the
      question; if a term is unavoidable, explain it in the answer.
    
      ANSWERS. Brief: two to four sentences. The short answer first, then
      one key Scripture reference or historical fact that supports it.
      End with a link to the full dossier, showing its number and title,
      e.g. "Read more: 01 · When Were You Born Again?" Link only to
      dossiers that exist; do not invent titles or links. Where the
      dossier presents the strongest case for the other side, say so
      briefly. Invite the reader in; do not close the question.
    
      NAMES. Name no preacher, church or person, as in the dossiers.
      Historical figures named in the dossiers (Luther, Bunyan,
      Margoschis) are fine.
    
      GROUPS. Use "Getting started" and the site's nine topic groups as
      headings: Baptism and the new birth; Worship and the Lord's Supper;
      The historic church and its creeds; Independent churches and who
      decides; Assurance and the inner life; Prophecy, revelation and
      reason; Pastors, preaching and power; Money, blessing and
      suffering; Family, work and everyday faith.
    
      GO DEEPER. Add two groups at the end that lead to the companion
      course, creedalfaith.org, and mark their links clearly as leading
      there:
       - "Learning the historic faith": a self-paced course in the
         fundamentals, written for readers in the four creedal traditions
         (Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran, Anglican). The reader can choose a
         tradition or read all four side by side, and each unit has a
         Complete and a Brief depth.
       - "Where did modern beliefs come from?": its Modern Church
         section, which traces Baptist, Pentecostal, charismatic and
         non-denominational beliefs back to where and when they began,
         and answers them from the creeds. It is written about these
         movements, not for them.
      Where a ThinkAsk answer touches a topic the course covers, add a
      secondary "Go deeper" link to the matching unit. Verify that each
      unit exists before linking to it.
    
      STARTER QUESTIONS (verify each against its dossier; reword, merge
      or drop as needed):
       Getting started: What is ThinkAsk, and why are the prompts
         published? Why are there three versions of every dossier? Is
         this site against my church? Is it wrong to ask questions about
         what my pastor teaches?
       Baptism: When was I born again? Is it a feeling, or something that
         happened to me? Did the early church baptize infants? Isn't baby
         dedication the same thing as infant baptism? Should I be
         baptized again? Aren't we just following Jesus' example when we
         are baptized? Pilgrim's Progress shaped my faith. Is anything
         missing from it?
       Worship: Is the Lord's Supper just a symbol? Our church has no
         liturgy. Is that more biblical? Why is the stage at the front
         instead of the altar? Since when did being a Christian become
         about "me" and not about Christ?
       The historic church: My pastor says the old churches are dead. Is
         he right? We have no creed but the Bible. Isn't that enough?
         Could the whole Church have been wrong for 1,500 years? Where
         does my church stand compared with the early Church? Are old
         heresies coming back in new churches? Does it matter what is
         preached, as long as Jesus' name is used? What did the
         missionaries who brought the gospel here actually preach?
       Independent churches: My church is non-denominational. Doesn't
         that mean it has no theology? We just follow Jesus. Why do we
         need anything written down? Can I change what I believe without
         noticing? Can a pastor hand the church to his son?
       Assurance: If I miss my quiet time, am I less spiritual? How can I
         know I am saved if it depends on my experience? Do I have to be
         clean of every sin before the Spirit will come? Do I really know
         God? Should a Christian be afraid of death?
       Prophecy and reason: Does Jesus need to speak to me every day for
         me to be a real Christian? How can we trust a pastor's personal
         revelation when it overrides the Bible? What if a prophecy does
         not come true? Do I have to switch off my mind to have faith?
         Is speaking in tongues a real language? Does God promise to heal
         everyone who has enough faith?
       Pastors and power: If I disagree with my pastor, am I fighting
         God? Do I need a pastor as my "covering" to be safe? Can a pastor
         ask God to kill those who disagree with him? Will God strike me
         down if I question the man of God? Is the pulpit the place to
         correct one person in the congregation? My pastor quotes a
         hundred verses. Doesn't that make it biblical? If "God told me,"
         can the church board still ask questions?
       Money and suffering: Should I just give and not ask how the money
         is used? Must I pay my tithe before I help someone in need? Can I
         earn God's favor by what I give? My pastor promised this month
         will be marvellous. What if it is not? If misfortune comes, is
         God punishing me?
       Family and work: Is serving at church more spiritual than my
         everyday job? Can my children see through a faith I only perform?
         My child loves music and sport. Is that taking them away from
         Jesus? I raised my child in church, and they walked away. Did
         God's promise fail?
       Learning the historic faith: Where do I start? What does the Creed
         actually say? What do Christians mean by the Trinity? Who decides
         what the Bible means? What does God do in baptism? Are the bread
         and wine only a reminder? How is a sinner put right with God?
         Can I know that I am saved? Why does historic worship follow a
         set order? How do I keep a rule of daily prayer that does not go
         cold? What has the Church always prayed for the sick, and what
         has it never promised? What happens when I die?
       Where modern beliefs came from: Where did my church's beliefs
         come from? How are the modern movements connected? Where did
         believer's baptism come from? The rapture and end-times charts?
         The altar call and the "second blessing"? Tongues in modern
         churches? Healing crusades? The prosperity gospel? Today's
         "apostles and prophets"? "Covering" and submission? The "Seven
         Mountains" mandate? Megachurches? How did these movements come
         to India? Who were the people who shaped them?
      Make sure every published dossier can be reached from at least one
      question.
    
      NOT YET ANSWERED. Some good beginner questions have no dossier yet.
      Do not answer them with invented links. List them at the end under
      "Suggested future dossiers", after checking whether the companion
      course already covers them.
    
      THE PAGE. An interactive HTML page that matches the site's theme,
      including its light and dark modes, and looks like part of the
      site rather than an add-on. Each question is an expandable card:
      the question visible, the answer and links on click, with "expand
      all" for readers who prefer to scroll. A simple search box. Links
      follow the reader's chosen version (Full, Quick read, Simple
      English). A prominent box at the top states the site's single most
      important idea: it does not ask you to trust it; it gives you the
      sources so you can check for yourself. Professional, suitable for
      publishing as it stands after a quick review, and easy to extend:
      adding a question for a new dossier should take a minute or two.
    
      HOME PAGE. A panel near the top of the home page, close to the
      introduction and the pinned dossier without crowding it, showing
      about six questions a first-time visitor is most likely to arrive
      with, linking to the full page, with a line under it that points
      to the companion course's "where did my church's beliefs come
      from?" material.
    Link to this page
    Short thinkask.ai/start
    Full thinkask.ai/start.html

    Both open the same page. To share one question, open it and use its own “Copy link” button.